Tokenized stocks, in detail

The reader’s version is the stocks page. This is the research behind it, kept whole, including the corrections, because a page about not publishing confident wrong answers should show its own. Numbers are as of 19 October 2026.

Would it pass the SEC’s rights test

On 17 September 2026 the SEC defined a “Tokenized NMS Stock” as one carrying the same dividends, the same votes and the same residual claim as the traditional share, and excluded synthetic exposure. Each issuer’s programme either meets that or does not, and the programme’s own legal page says which. Ondo’s token is “a structured note: a debt instrument”; each xStock is “a bearer debt instrument classified as a tracker certificate” that “does not confer shareholder voting rights”; Robinhood’s are “tokenized debt securities” that “do not grant investors any legal or beneficial rights in” the underlying. Those three programmes are most of the priced value. Superstate’s Opening Bell tokens are the shares on the company’s register and pass; none of them has a public price yet, so they carry no value here.

Priced value that passes: 0.0%. Fails: 98.9%. Unknown or unclassified: 1.1%.

IssuerStructureRights testPriced tokensTickers readValuePasses
xStocks debt-linked note fails 36 12 $659M 0.0%
Ondo debt-linked note fails 85 11 $606M 0.0%
bStocks custodied entitlement fails 21 3 $403M 0.0%
Robinhood debt-linked note fails 32 6 $86.2M 0.0%
Backpack unclassified unclassified 12 0 $20.2M 0.0%
rStock unknown fails 3 2 $545K 0.0%

“Tickers read” is how many of the issuer’s tokens are named in the registry row by row; the rest are attributed from the programme, because a structured note is a structured note whichever stock it tracks. The verdict is from the issuer document linked on every registry row; “unknown” means the document did not state an element: Dinari’s page says only that a dShare is backed 1:1 by a security, and Coinbase’s says dividends are reinvested and voting is for vested holders only, and neither states the claim in liquidation. It is never rounded to a guess. bStocks are ADGM certificates representing an interest in shares the issuer holds, “not direct ownership”, so they fail without being debt.

Four markets, one company, no shared oracle

Correction, 28 July 2026. This section used to be headed “Price where none exists” and opened “SpaceX is private. There is no NYSE quote.” SpaceX listed on Nasdaq as SPCX on 12 June 2026, and that claim was wrong here for six weeks. It is corrected rather than deleted.

What is still true, and still measured, is the agreement itself:

IssuerTickerPrice24h volumeDeviationVerdict
bStocks SPCXB $148 $48.4M -0.02% ok
Robinhood SPCX $148 $16.1M 0.07% ok
Backpack SPCX $148 $14.5M -0.09% ok
xStocks SPCXX $148 $6.7M 0.00% ok
Ondo SPCXON $148 $3.2M 0.21% ok

Independent order books, no shared oracle between them, pricing the same company within cents of each other. That is a real finding about how tokenized equity markets behave, and it does not depend on the underlying being private. The open question about SpaceX resolved the dull way: these markets priced it near $110 while the IPO priced at $135, and the share has since traded down to the tokens’ level. The gap was a current price compared against a historical one, the same class of mistake as comparing a single-chain supply to a multi-chain total.

Premium against the real share: withdrawn

This page used to publish a premium for every tokenized stock against the real listed share. It was removed on 31 July 2026 because it was wrong, and the way it was wrong is worth stating rather than quietly deleting.

The reference was stale and the guard did not catch it. Every row compared a live 24/7 token quote against a stock close from up to 37.8 hours earlier. The staleness ceiling was set at 96 hours, so all 183 rows passed while the equity feed sat at one successful run against hourly token prices. Bloom Energy published +35.04%. Eleven boards read above +14% at once. None of it was a premium; it was a full trading session of ordinary movement charged to the tokens.

And some token quotes are simply wrong. After refreshing the reference to 13.8 hours the worst case barely moved: one tokenized CrowdStrike still read a 300% premium, quoting about $741 against a real share near $179. That is not staleness, it is a bad price, and no reference age fixes it.

The honest version of this comparison needs an equity price sampled close to when the token was quoted. A daily close cannot do it, because the whole point of these instruments is that they trade while the exchange is shut. Blue Ocean ATS covers 20:00 to 04:00 ET and is the obvious input; the weekend remains genuinely uncovered by any US venue. Until then there is no premium column.

Does the 24/7 market know where the stock opens?

This is the strongest claim made for tokenized equities: the exchange shuts, the token keeps trading, so the token should tell you tomorrow’s price. We measure it rather than repeat it, and the first version of this section got it wrong.

We were scoring against the wrong price. A quote taken at 2am ET is predicting the opening bell, not 4pm. Measured against the close, the token looked useless and this page concluded it was “pinned near the prior close rather than discovering a price”. Measured against the open, the median realized move is 1.01x what the token implied. It sizes overnight gaps nearly correctly. Against the close the same quotes give 2.00x, and that gap is not a failure of the token: it is the trading session the token could not have known about.

We still will not give you a hit rate. Against the open the direction is right on 93 of 98 name-days, which looks spectacular and is not evidence. On each day measured, 85 to 96% of the tokenized signals pointed the same way and 74 to 96% of the opens did too, because both are dominated by one market-wide overnight move. That is three independent observations, not 98. The magnitude numbers above need no such assumption, which is why they are the ones published.

And one more limit, because it is the one a professional would raise first. US stocks already trade overnight on Blue Ocean ATS, 20:00 to 04:00 ET Sunday through Thursday, since 2021. Every snapshot behind the numbers above but one was taken inside those hours, so a conventional US venue was pricing the same share at the same moment and the token may be tracking it rather than discovering anything. Split by whether any US venue was open, the weekend observation sizes the gap at 1.03x and the Blue Ocean-overlapping ones at 1.25x, but that is one day against two. The hours genuinely nothing else covers are Friday 20:00 to Sunday 20:00 ET, and that is where this dataset can say something no other source can.

Which version should you hold?

Prices are held together by arbitrage against redemption, not by an oracle. If a token drifts above the real share you buy the share, mint the token, and sell it. So a token’s distance from its peers is a readout of whether that issuer’s redemption actually works.

StockNameTypeIssuersLiquid24h volumeWorst spreadProblems
SPCX SpaceX equity 5 5 $88.9M 0.2% 0
NVDA NVIDIA equity 6 4 $40.1M 15.9% 2
TSLA Tesla equity 5 4 $37.4M 85.4% 1
SNDK Sandisk equity 5 5 $36.1M 0.3% 0
GOOGL Alphabet Class A equity 4 4 $19.2M 0.1% 0
QQQ Invesco QQQ ETF etf 3 3 $16.2M 0.3% 0
CRCL Circle Internet Group equity 3 3 $15.9M 0.0% 0
META Meta Platforms equity 4 4 $13.1M 0.2% 0
MU Micron Technology equity 4 4 $10.1M 0.5% 0
SPY SPDR S&P 500 ETF etf 3 2 $9.3M 10.7% 1
COIN Coinbase Global equity 4 4 $9.1M 0.1% 0
AMZN Amazon.com equity 3 3 $7.6M 0.1% 0
AAPL Apple equity 3 3 $7.1M 0.1% 0
MSFT Microsoft equity 4 4 $5.7M 0.3% 0
MSTR Strategy (formerly MicroStrategy) equity 3 3 $4.4M 0.1% 0
PLTR Palantir Technologies equity 4 4 $4.2M 0.2% 0
AMD Advanced Micro Devices equity 4 4 $4.0M 0.5% 0
COST Costco equity 2 2 $3.7M 0.2% 0
AAOI Applied Optoelectronics equity 3 2 $3.6M 1.0% 1
MRVL Marvell Technology equity 5 2 $3.4M 0.4% 0
CRWV CoreWeave equity 3 2 $3.4M 0.7% 0
HIMS Hims & Hers Health equity 2 2 $3.0M 0.1% 0
AVGO Broadcom equity 5 3 $3.0M 0.5% 1
KO Coca-Cola equity 2 1 $2.6M — 0
INTC Intel equity 4 4 $2.5M 0.3% 0
BABA Alibaba Group equity 3 3 $2.3M 0.8% 0
WDC Western Digital equity 2 2 $2.1M 0.1% 0
RKLB Rocket Lab equity 3 2 $1.8M 1.6% 1
QCOM Qualcomm equity 3 2 $1.6M 0.8% 0
ASML ASML Holding equity 2 1 $1.5M — 0
GME GameStop equity 3 3 $1.4M 0.9% 0
GLW Corning equity 3 2 $1.4M 3.1% 1
XOM Exxon Mobil equity 2 1 $1.4M — 0
BMNR BitMine Immersion Technologies equity 2 1 $1.4M — 0
LLY Eli Lilly equity 3 2 $1.3M 0.2% 0
IBM IBM equity 2 2 $1.2M 1.1% 0
CVX Chevron equity 2 1 $1.0M — 0
HOOD Robinhood Markets equity 2 2 $1.0M 0.2% 0
BE Bloom Energy equity 2 2 $983K 0.0% 0
ADBE Adobe equity 2 1 $849K — 0
QBTS D-Wave Quantum equity 2 1 $777K — 0
AMAT Applied Materials equity 2 1 $679K — 0
ACN Accenture equity 2 1 $572K — 0
MA Mastercard equity 2 1 $527K — 0
BA Boeing equity 2 1 $505K — 0
ASTS AST SpaceMobile equity 3 1 $499K — 0
APLD Applied Digital equity 2 1 $175K — 0
SBET SharpLink Gaming equity 2 1 $158K — 0
CORZ Core Scientific equity 2 1 $153K — 0
ABT Abbott equity 2 0 $66K — 0
ABBV AbbVie equity 2 0 $15K — 0
CRWD CrowdStrike equity 2 0 $3K — 0
APP AppLovin equity 2 0 $2K — 0

Issuers to avoid

Two independent failures at once: no meaningful volume and a price adrift from peers. An issuer can wash trade its own token, but it cannot make competitors agree with a wrong price, so failing both is a strong signal.

StockIssuerTickerPricePeers sayOff by24h volume
TSLA rStock TSLAR $54 $367 -85.4% $3
NVDA rStock NVDAR $183 $217 -15.9% $20
SPY rStock SPYR $690 $773 -10.7% $8
GLW Robinhood GLW $135 $131 3.1% $11
NVDA Backpack NVDA $224 $217 3.0% $34
RKLB Backpack RKLB $52 $51 1.6% $8,884
AAOI Robinhood AAOI $75 $76 -1.0% $1,217
AVGO Backpack AVGO $332 $334 -0.5% $5,443

Qualified liquidity

Every liquidity figure on these pages is a qualified figure: the sum of pools that pass a stated plausibility test, applied per pool, with the excluded amount published beside it so the derivation is checkable. A pool cannot hold more of a token than exists, and pools whose claimed depth fails that test do not count.

NetworkAll poolsQualifiedExcludedExcluded %Pools excluded
bsc $1,154,161,439 $38,021,344 $1,116,140,095 96.7% 1
robinhood $328,785,226 $253,188,634 $75,596,593 23.0% 2
solana $57,115,447 $57,115,447 $0 0.0% 0
eth $1,812,790 $1,812,790 $0 0.0% 0
arbitrum $37 $37 $0 0.0% 0
hyperevm $8 $8 $0 0.0% 0

On Robinhood Chain, when this was first measured, all pools together came to $2.97 billion and the qualified figure was $33 million. One pool was the entire difference: it had recorded zero trades in 24 hours and quoted NVDA at $2.87 against a real closing price near $197. The nvda in that pool’s name is not NVIDIA; it is a token named to resemble it.

Where these actually trade

A token existing on a chain tells you nothing about whether it trades there. A dead pool is worse than uninteresting: its stale price still gets quoted. One such pool priced NVIDIA at $1,180 against a real $208, a 467% premium on zero volume.

ChainTokensActiveGhostPoolsDead pools %Liquidity24h volume
robinhood 19 17 2 6,360 98.7 $253M $57.7M
solana 11 10 1 7,433 99.5 $57.1M $42.0M
bsc 16 5 11 1,944 98.7 $38.0M $23.8M
eth 11 1 10 321 99.7 $1.8M $391K
arbitrum 2 0 2 2 100.0 $37 $0
hyperevm 1 0 1 1 100.0 $8 $0

They exist everywhere and trade almost nowhere.

Ghost listings

Deployed, quotable, and with no live venue at all:

TokenIssuerChainPoolsLiquidity24h volume
Eli Lilly • Robinhood Token Robinhood robinhood 211 $4,117,014 $212,473
Boeing • Robinhood Token Robinhood robinhood 205 $3,436,069 $18,396
NVIDIA (Ondo Tokenized Stock) Ondo bsc 145 $165,373 $2,217
SpaceX xStock xStocks eth 57 $104,602 $683
SpaceX xStock xStocks bsc 19 $7,898 $24
MicroStrategy xStock xStocks eth 11 $11,311 $12
NVIDIA xStock xStocks eth 9 $12,502 $0
SP500 xStock xStocks eth 9 $2,634 $0
NVIDIA (Ondo Tokenized Stock) Ondo solana 5 $11,023 $12
Circle xStock xStocks bsc 5 $2,250 $0
Circle xStock xStocks eth 5 $6,437 $0
SP500 xStock xStocks bsc 4 $809 $0

Showing 12 of 27.

How this is judged

A venue counts as live only if it moved at least $10K in 24 hours and holds at least $100K of liquidity. Both thresholds are configuration, recorded on every row, so any number here can be traced to the floor that produced it. Raised on 28 July 2026, from $100 and $1,000. Those were not a floor: $100 of daily volume is noise, and $1,000 of depth means a $500 order moves the price against you. The new pair is the honest reading of “a retail-size trade clears here”. It cut the live count from 44 to 23, which makes the finding stronger, not weaker.

The full per-token venue table is on the audit console. See the methodology for the rest of the assumptions.